Sometimes in Jamaica we hear something enough times and eventually start repeating it as fact.
That seems to be what happened with Ziggy Marley.
The story became that Ziggy Marley performed a benefit concert for the Israeli Defense Forces and raised $60 million for them.
That is not an accurate description of what happened.
Ziggy attended a Friends of the Israel Defense Forces gala in Los Angeles in 2018. The event itself reportedly raised approximately $60 million. Ziggy was there. His participation can be criticized. People are free to question why a Marley would associate himself with an event connected to the Israeli military.
But saying Ziggy Marley personally staged a concert and raised $60 million for the IDF is something different.
Facts still matter, especially when you are talking about somebody's name.
This is where I also have a problem with Queen Ifrica jumping into the issue and repeating information in a way that helps create this picture of Ziggy Marley as some kind of financier of the Israeli military.
Ziggy himself responded publicly after Queen Ifrica's comments and said he had never raised money for the IDF or any military.
Before we condemn somebody, especially another Jamaican artist, shouldn't we at least get the information straight?
Queen Ifrica is entitled to criticize Ziggy.
She is entitled to support Palestine.
She is entitled to question his decisions.
What she is not entitled to do is become the final authority on Rastafari, Bob Marley or what every person carrying the Marley name is supposed to believe.
Sometimes Queen Ifrica likes to swerve into these public controversies with tremendous certainty, but certainty does not automatically make somebody correct.
Rastafari is bigger than any artist.
Nobody owns it.
Nobody gets to stand at the gate and decide who is sufficiently Rasta according to their personal interpretation.
And that brings me back to Ziggy.
Ziggy Marley is not Bob Marley.
That might sound simple, but I don't think people truly accept it.
Jamaicans have almost turned Bob Marley into an office that one of his sons is supposed to inherit.
We expect the locks.
The consciousness.
The African identity.
The rebelliousness.
The militant politics.
The courage.
The woman beside him.
The words coming out of his mouth.
Everything.
Then when his children live differently, people behave as though they betrayed their father.
But Bob Marley was an extraordinary individual.
Even among great reggae artists Bob was different.
Bob was almost like a musical soldier.
Give Bob Marley injustice and he would find a song.
Give him political violence and he would walk directly into it.
The man got shot and still performed.
Jamaica was tearing itself apart politically and Bob eventually stood onstage at the One Love Peace Concert, took Michael Manley and Edward Seaga by their hands and physically joined them above his head.
That was not normal entertainer behavior.
That was Bob Marley.
Bob operated almost like a man who believed music had given him a diplomatic assignment from Jah.
You cannot expect every son he produced to have that temperament.
Ziggy doesn't.
Stephen doesn't.
Damian doesn't.
Julian doesn't.
Ky-Mani doesn't.
They are their own men.
Talented men, yes.
Marley men, yes.
But none of them is Bob Marley.
And Ziggy's life became especially complicated because he married directly into one of the world's deepest political and historical conflicts.
His wife Orly is Israeli, born into a family of Iranian heritage.
They have been together for decades.
They have children.
They have a family.
What exactly are people asking Ziggy to do now?
Wake up one morning and decide his wife represents Babylon?
Tell his children one half of their heritage is unacceptable?
Destroy a marriage because people on social media decided his father's politics should control his household?
Life does not work that way.
You can disagree with Israel's government and its treatment of Palestinians without demanding that Ziggy stop loving an Israeli woman.
Those are two completely different things.
I believe the Palestinian people deserve freedom, dignity and a future in which they are not permanently living under domination.
I also believe Israeli civilians have a right to live without being murdered.
Those two beliefs do not cancel each other.
The innocent child in Gaza and the innocent child in Israel did not create this conflict.
Maybe this is exactly where Ziggy Marley should be.
Right there in the middle of Babylon.
Maybe everybody is looking at his marriage as a contradiction when it could become his greatest opportunity.
A Jamaican Rastaman.
The son of Bob Marley.
Married into an Israeli family with Iranian roots.
Children carrying all of those histories in the same blood.
Maybe Jah didn't put him there by accident.
Perhaps Ziggy's greatest contribution will not be choosing one people over another.
Maybe it will be standing between them.
That is where I believe Bob Marley would have taken it further.
Bob would probably have driven everybody crazy.
Because Bob would have challenged Israel while also challenging Palestinian leadership.
He would have spoken for the dead children.
He would have spoken against terrorism.
He would have spoken against occupation and oppression.
Then Bob would probably have started calling people and trying to get Israelis and Palestinians on the same stage.
Because that was Bob's mentality.
Turn confrontation into music.
Turn music into conversation.
Turn conversation into reconciliation.
He tried it in Jamaica.
That was his weapon.
Ziggy may never have that militant spirit.
And that is okay.
Stop demanding that the man become his father.
But Ziggy does have something Bob never had.
He has a family connection directly inside this conflict.
That gives him an unusual responsibility.
Instead of shouting down his concerts, maybe people should challenge him to use that position.
Go further, Ziggy.
Speak for Palestinian freedom.
Speak for Israeli humanity.
Bring musicians together.
Visit both communities.
Let Palestinian children hear Marley music.
Let Israeli children hear the same music.
Put people who have been taught to fear each other in the same room.
That would be Marley work.
And Queen Ifrica or anybody else who genuinely believes in Rastafari should be encouraging truth before accusation.
Because Rastafari without truth becomes another costume.
Locks don't make truth.
A stage name doesn't make truth.
Saying Jah repeatedly doesn't make truth.
Truth makes truth.
So criticize Ziggy where criticism is deserved.
Question the IDF gala.
Question his political statements.
Question his closeness to Israeli institutions if you believe those relationships deserve scrutiny.
But stop turning disputed or exaggerated information into gospel because it sounds good in an argument.
And stop demanding that Ziggy Marley spend his entire life trying to become Bob Marley.
There was one Bob.
Ziggy's assignment might be something completely different.
Maybe the son of the man who once brought two Jamaican political enemies together has somehow found himself inside another historic division.
If that is where life has placed him, perhaps the question should not be whether Ziggy is enough like Bob.
The question should be what Ziggy intends to do with the position Jah has given him.

